Peter Pan Wendy John Michael Captain Hook Tinkerbell Tigerlily Mermaids: Marina Coral Adella Fairies: Mushroom Twig Petal The Darlings: Mr. Darling Mrs. Darling Croc Peter’s Shadow | Kolten Keller Éowyn Ralston William Turner Liam Grimaldo Raedin Ralston Aubrey Gast Grey Grimaldo Peyton Turner (US Tiger Lily) Ella Smith (US Fairy) Annalisa Soto Addison Wallace Phoebe Diaz (US Wendy) Afton Ralston Gavin Jacobs (US Hook) Kylie Beittenmiller Alice Dyer Alice Dyer | Lost boys: Curly Slightly Nibs Tootles Twin 1 Twin 2 Lost girls: Willow Poppy Juniper Ivy Ensemble Ensemble Pirates: Smee Bill Jukes Flint Starkey Cookson Ensemble Ensemble | Cooper Stacy Jackson Kartchner (US Peter) Liam Drake (US Michael) Michael Godfrey (US John) Caroline Sheppard (US Croc) Micah Scharmann Emerson Windle Annabelle Whitney Livy Edwards Averi Jacobs (US Tinkerbell) Lillian Mertz HB Hartman Nathaniel Brewer Lucian Finney Porter Turner Elijah Scharmann Donald Prewitt Amelia Kitzmiller Asher Andrysiak |